The curtain has officially closed on another frustrating Mets season—and wouldn’t you know it, Pete Alonso decided to toss in a final plot twist just as the credits rolled. After the Mets got shut out 4–0 by the Marlins to end their season, the Polar Bear himself announced he’s opting out of his current contract. That’s right—Alonso is hitting the free agent market again this offseason.
Alonso Bets on Himself After Career Rebound
Now, let’s be clear—this isn’t coming out of nowhere. Remember, Alonso already dipped his toes in free agency last winter, only to find the water a bit chillier than expected. No long-term bites. No mega-deal. Just a two-year, $54 million band-aid deal with the Mets that gave him an opt-out for 2026. Well, he’s tearing that clause off a year early. And you can bet your Citi Field hot dog this time, he’s betting big on himself.
And honestly, after the season he just had, who can blame him?
In 2024, Alonso struggled. That was the year his bat seemed to lose its thunder—he barely cracked a .240 average, struck out 172 times, and put up a career-worst OPS of .788. Not great when you’re trying to sell yourself as one of the game’s elite power bats. But 2025? Whole different story. Alonso turned up the volume and reminded everyone why he’s a five-time All-Star: .272 average, .524 slugging, 38 home runs, and 126 RBIs. That’s not just a bounce-back—that’s a statement.
Still Hope He Will Resign For Mets?
Alonso is officially a free man. But don’t get too misty-eyed, Mets fans. The guy made it clear he still loves the orange and blue. “It’s been a pleasure,” he said. “Nothing is guaranteed… but I love being a Met.” That’s classic Pete—grateful, emotional, but also real. And maybe, just maybe, he’s leaving the door slightly cracked open for a return.
Of course, the baseball world knows how quickly love can turn into leverage. Alonso’s comments were gracious, sure—but they also carried a tone of “your move, front office.” He knows he’s one of the top bats hitting the market, and he’s positioned himself perfectly to make teams—including the Mets—put their money where their mouth is.
Will Steve Cohen Go All-In—Again?
But here’s the million-dollar question: will Steve Cohen and the Mets open the vault for him to stay? After dropping over $340 million on payroll and still missing the playoffs by one measly game, the front office has some soul-searching to do. Is Alonso the guy you invest another $200 million into? Or is this where the team pivots?
The clock is ticking. The market is watching. And Pete Alonso is about to test whether his bat is finally back to being worth the blockbuster contract he’s been chasing. One thing’s for sure—this offseason just got a whole lot more interesting.
