The Atlanta Braves are at a crossroads when it comes to shoring up their shortstop position. With the offseason heating up, names like Willy Adames and Bo Bichette dominate the rumor mill, but a fresh suggestion offers an intriguing alternative for Braves fans.
According to Lindsay Crosby of Chicago Cubs on SI, the Braves could look to the North Side of Chicago and strike a deal for Nico Hoerner. Now, Hoerner might not have the same star power as some other names floating around, but there’s plenty of logic behind this potential move.
Hoerner is not just another name in the lineup; he’s the kind of versatile, defensively elite player who could provide Atlanta with the stability they need. Crosby emphasizes that Hoerner’s value goes beyond just being a shortstop—his experience at second base and his Gold Glove-winning ability make him a dynamic option.
Over his 2024 season, Hoerner’s numbers were solid: batting .273 with a .708 OPS, seven home runs, 48 RBIs, and 31 stolen bases in 151 games. Those 31 steals? That’s the kind of speed that adds a whole new dimension to any lineup, especially if the Braves decide to be more conservative with Ronald Acuña Jr.’s usage on the basepaths in the coming seasons.
So, what’s the catch? Well, every good trade proposal comes with one. To land Hoerner, the Braves might have to give up a key piece of their own—top catching prospect Drake Baldwin. Now, this isn’t just any prospect; Baldwin was the Braves’ Minor League Player of the Year in 2024. The thought of letting go of such a valuable asset might make some Braves fans pause. A one-for-one swap, however, isn’t unreasonable when considering what the team would gain.
Crosby’s logic checks out. Hoerner is already a proven Major Leaguer, a steady presence with both a strong glove and a consistent bat. When you compare the price tags of other potential targets, like Bichette—whose 2024 season was riddled with injuries—Hoerner becomes an attractive option that doesn’t gut the farm system.
Yes, this might feel like a backup plan kind of move, but it’s one that could make a lot of sense for both sides. The Cubs would receive a promising young talent in Baldwin, while the Braves fill their shortstop slot with someone who can contribute immediately and for years to come. It’s the kind of win-win trade that might not generate huge headlines but could pay off when it matters most.
