The Red Sox and Cardinals are becoming regular dance partners this offseason, and the music may not be stopping just yet.
After two impactful trades between Boston and St. Louis already this winter, a third potential deal is now circling the rumor mill. According to reports, the Red Sox are setting their sights on versatile infielder Brendan Donovan, a player who might just be the missing piece in Boston’s infield puzzle.
The Red Sox Keep Pressing the Gas Pedal This Offseason
Let’s rewind for a moment. Boston has already pulled two key pieces out of the Gateway City, first, snagging veteran starter Sonny Gray to firm up the rotation behind Garrett Crochet. Then, they filled their long-vacant first base hole with the acquisition of Willson Contreras, a move that not only brought offensive thump but positional flexibility. Both trades addressed glaring weaknesses. Both came at strategic moments in the offseason. And now, there’s a sense that Craig Breslow isn’t quite finished with his roster retool.
Brendan Donovan Brings the Versatility Boston Needs
Enter Brendan Donovan, the Swiss Army knife of the Cardinals’ roster, a former Gold Glove utility winner (2022) and a first-time All-Star in 2025. He’s the type of player who quietly makes a team better every day. Across nearly 2,000 plate appearances, Donovan has slashed a highly respectable .282/.361/.411, adding 40 homers and nearly 100 doubles. His ability to play multiple positions, particularly second base and left field, fits precisely into Boston’s current needs.
And let’s be honest: the keystone hasn’t been a strength for Boston lately. David Hamilton, Romy Gonzalez, and Kristian Campbell failed to seize the job in 2025, and while Campbell holds long-term promise, the Sox can’t afford to wait. Donovan offers immediate stability, an above-average bat, and the kind of roster versatility that winning teams crave.
Competition Heating Up, but Familiarity Favors Boston
But Boston isn’t alone in the chase. The San Francisco Giants and Seattle Mariners have reportedly jumped into the Donovan sweepstakes, according to reports. Both clubs are hungry for a controllable, productive infielder with positional flexibility, and Donovan fits the bill.
Still, history matters. With two trades already in the books, the Red Sox and Cardinals clearly have momentum and familiarity on their side. Could that be the edge that leads to a third deal?
Stay tuned. Because if the past few weeks are any indication, this Red Sox-Cardinals pipeline might still have fuel left in the tank.
