The idea of Bo Bichette wearing a Braves uniform has Braves fans buzzing, especially after Bob Nightengale’s recent comments suggesting the All-Star shortstop’s days in Toronto are numbered.
With Bichette’s contract running through 2025, Nightengale’s implication that he’s “as good as gone” has fueled speculation about a potential trade this offseason.
Braves fans are frustrated by Orlando Arcia’s underwhelming offensive output in 2024. The thought of Bichette slotting into the lineup offers a tantalizing prospect. But is this potential move realistic—or even worthwhile?
Bichette’s Financial Hurdle for the Braves
First, there’s the financial hurdle. Bichette is projected to make roughly $17.6 million in 2025, a figure that starkly contrasts the Braves’ conservative spending habits this offseason.
Atlanta seems to be prioritizing cost-effective signings and internal development over splashing cash on big contracts.
For a Bichette deal to even be feasible, Toronto would likely need to absorb a significant portion of his salary—a tall ask for a player of his caliber.
Then there’s the matter of trade compensation. Bichette’s value as a proven shortstop with star potential means the Blue Jays won’t let him go cheaply. Some pundits have floated the idea of Atlanta parting with a top prospect, but that’s where the waters get murky.
Harrison Smajovits of Atlanta Braves on SI has already expressed reluctance to see Atlanta trade a promising left-handed pitcher, particularly someone like 2024 first-rounder Cam Caminiti.
The more valuable the prospect package, the more salary relief the Braves might demand. This creates a delicate balance that could ultimately scuttle negotiations.
Does Bichette Bring a Lift in Performance?
Let’s not forget the most important question. Would Bichette actually improve Atlanta’s lineup? The answer seems obvious on paper.
His track record of All-Star appearances and solid hitting credentials outshine Arcia’s. However, both players struggled in 2024, with Bichette posting a .598 OPS—lower than Arcia’s .625.
While Bichette’s past performances hint at a higher ceiling, the Braves would be betting on him rebounding from an injury-plagued year. That’s a risk they’d have to weigh carefully.
Nightengale’s report may have sparked hope in Braves Country, but a trade for Bichette is far from a slam dunk. Unless the Blue Jays become desperate to offload their star shortstop, Atlanta might find the cost—both financial and in prospects—too steep. For now, fans can dream, but the reality remains cloudy.
