Shane Bieber is returning to where it all started: the Cleveland Guardians. Some folks had visions of Bieber donning an Atlanta Braves jersey, while others were convinced he’d join the likes of the St. Louis Cardinals or the Texas Rangers. But nope, Cleveland said, “Hold up, we’re not letting him go just yet,” and they made sure of it.
The Guardians didn’t exactly break the bank for this deal. Bieber signed on for a one-year contract worth $14 million, with a $16 million player option for 2026. Sounds like a risk-managed package doesn’t it? There is an unexpected side to this though. Bieber actually turned down bigger offers from elsewhere to stay in Cleveland, according to Jon Heyman.
And let’s not sugarcoat things: Bieber’s return comes with some major question marks. Remember, he’s coming off Tommy John surgery and won’t be at full strength until mid-2025. The Guardians are banking on a second-half resurgence and a postseason push under new skipper Stephen Vogt.
Now, let’s talk numbers. Before injury derailed his 2024 season, Bieber only pitched in two games. But in those 12 innings? He didn’t give up a single run and racked up 20 strikeouts. That’s the kind of dominance Cleveland fans are hoping he brings back to the mound. If Bieber returns to form, snagging him for $14 million will look like an absolute steal.
Of course, there’s always a risk when you’re dealing with a pitcher rehabbing from major surgery. But if the Guardians can manage Bieber’s comeback and he delivers even a slice of his All-Star, Cy Young-winning brilliance, this deal could be a masterstroke. Even if 2025 isn’t perfect, the 2026 player option gives Cleveland another bite at the apple. Braves fans dreamed of pairing him with Chris Sale who just won the NL Cy Young this past season.
Let’s not forget — Shane Bieber’s got the hardware. A two-time All-Star. A Cy Young winner. He’s still only 30 by the time the 2025 season kicks off. If that elbow holds up, there’s plenty of time for Bieber to add more accolades. Time will tell, but the Atlanta Braves may be kicking themselves halfway through the season for missing this opportunity.
