The Atlanta Braves face a critical moment in their 2025 roster planning, particularly with their starting rotation. Losing Max Fried to the Yankees on an eight-year, $218 million deal was a gut punch.
Fried had been a reliable presence in Atlanta’s rotation, sliding in seamlessly behind ace Chris Sale. Without him, the Braves must reconfigure, and while there’s still plenty to work with, there’s no ignoring the gap.
What the Braves Have Now
Atlanta’s rotation isn’t barren by any means. Spencer Strider is set to return from injury, and the reliable duo of Reynaldo López and Spencer Schwellenbach will bolster the lineup. However, there’s a big caveat—none of these pitchers are proven bets to surpass 150 innings in a season.
A durable, innings-eating arm is a premium the Braves can’t overlook as they aim for sustained contention. This need places them squarely in the market for additional pitching help.
Could Pittsburgh Be the Answer?
The Pittsburgh Pirates have emerged as an intriguing trade partner. They are known for developing pitching depth but struggling with their offensive lineup.
Pittsburgh has been an active seller, already trading Luis Ortiz to Cleveland. One name floating around in trade speculation is Mitch Keller, a 2023 All-Star who could be a perfect fit for Atlanta.
Now two years into a five-year, $77 million deal, Keller represents the kind of stability Atlanta’s rotation could use. His 2024 ERA of 4.25 might not sparkle, but his ability to eat innings—372 1/3 over the last two seasons—makes him a valuable asset.
The Braves could also consider Jared Jones, though his age, team control, and potential price tag make him a less likely acquisition compared to Keller.
A Trade Proposal That Works?
John Buhler of FanSided floated an enticing trade package: Braves outfielder Jarred Kelenic and top pitching prospect Hurston Waldrep for Keller. This proposal makes sense on several levels.
For Atlanta, acquiring Keller would solidify their rotation with a durable mid-rotation starter who complements their current arms. It also frees up left field for a potential upgrade, giving the Braves the flexibility to explore additional moves.
For Pittsburgh, the return package addresses their current needs. Kelenic is a young outfielder with upside. Waldrep, a high-ceiling pitching prospect, could bolster their farm system or make an impact in the near future. It’s a forward-looking deal for a team building for a stronger tomorrow.
The Big Picture For the Braves
While it’s tough to part with prospects like Waldrep or players like Kelenic, the Braves need to prioritize immediate competitiveness.
Locking in a dependable starter like Keller could be the missing piece that keeps their rotation strong and their postseason hopes alive. With Fried gone, a proactive move is essential.
