Wonder what truly creates hidden value in baseball? Arbitration extensions just might be the secret sauce. These deals work differently than the wild free-agent market frenzies you see splashed across headlines every winter. They happen earlier, before players can test open bidding.
Ready for a tour of baseball’s 25 best arbitration extensions? These deals showcase how clever teams spotted talent early, locked it down affordably, and built championship-caliber rosters while other teams paid retail.
25: Evan Longoria (Tampa Bay Rays, 2009)
The Rays secured their cornerstone third baseman with an 8-year, $102.9 million extension after his Rookie of the Year campaign. This happened just six days into his MLB career. Bold.
By moving before Longoria reached “super-two” status, Tampa Bay saved millions during his arbitration years. For perspective, teammate David Price later cost significantly more through the standard arbitration process.
Longoria delivered tremendous value throughout the contract. He later signed another team-friendly extension in 2013. The Rays finally traded him to the Giants in 2017, ending an era where his affordable contract helped the perpetually budget-conscious team compete with the AL East giants.
24: Jimmy Rollins (Philadelphia Phillies, 2006)
The Phillies hit the jackpot with Rollins’ 6-year, $104.8 million deal in 2006. While many extensions age like milk left in the sun, this one matured like fine wine, especially compared to the contracts teammates Chase Utley and Ryan Howard later received.
Rollins consistently outperformed his salary during this period. He ranked among baseball’s elite shortstops while collecting MVP hardware and Gold Glove recognition. His leadership helped guide the Phillies to their 2008 World Series title.
His contract resembled finding a vintage Rolex at a yard sale—premium performance at bargain prices.
23: Robinson Canó (New York Yankees, 2008)
Ever wonder why the normally spend-happy Yankees let Canó walk to Seattle? His 6-year extension generated $105.8 million in surplus value while wearing pinstripes. During this span, Canó delivered multiple 8-WAR seasons and finished in the top six of MVP voting multiple times.
His departure marked a rare instance where the Yankees broke from tradition by not keeping a homegrown star. The decision seems even more puzzling considering how well Canó performed during his first three years with the Mariners after leaving New York.
Few middle infielders have provided more bang for the buck during the modern era than Canó did during this contract period.
22: Chris Sale (Chicago White Sox, 2013)
Sale’s 7-year deal with the White Sox accumulated $106.6 million in surplus value. This extension established him as one of baseball’s premier pitchers alongside names like Kershaw, Verlander, and Scherzer.
During this contract, Sale recorded six straight seasons finishing in the top five of Cy Young voting. He even delivered a spectacular 300-strikeout season. His $15 million salary in 2019 looks almost comical compared to the $30 million annually he commanded afterward.
Injuries unfortunately derailed his later performance after the Red Sox acquired him. Still, few pitching contracts have delivered more value relative to cost in the modern era.
21: Freddie Freeman (Atlanta Braves, 2014)
Freeman’s 8-year contract created $107.6 million in surplus value for the Braves. Unlike some bargain-bin specials on this list, he wasn’t dramatically underpaid, but he consistently performed at an elite level that exceeded his compensation.
He averaged over 5 WAR per season from 2016-2021, including his MVP campaign. Braves fans felt the sting when the team let him walk after years of stellar production. Matt Olson’s arrival softened the blow, but Freeman’s consistent excellence made his contract a tremendous value.
Freeman’s steady production made him baseball’s version of that reliable neighborhood restaurant—nothing flashy on the outside, but always delivering quality above its price point.
20: George Brett (Kansas City Royals, 1979)
Brett’s 3-year Royals contract generated an astonishing $110.2 million in surplus value during the embryonic days of free agency. After the reserve clause crumbled in 1975, baseball’s economic structure fundamentally changed.
Brett won the 1980 MVP award while earning merely league average salary that season. His performance throughout this contract period blew past expectations, establishing him as one of the game’s elite hitters.
This deal highlights how drastically baseball’s financial landscape has evolved. Modern stars would sooner play in wooden cleats than accept similar terms relative to their production.
19: José Bautista (Toronto Blue Jays, 2011)
Following his breakout power season, Bautista’s 6-year deal with the Blue Jays generated $111.7 million in surplus value. Many doubted whether his sudden transformation into a slugger would last. He answered those questions with resounding home runs.
Bautista led the league in home runs again in 2011. His OPS+ soared during most of the extension while he collected multiple top-10 MVP finishes. Only in the final year did his production significantly decline.
His later attempt to secure a massive free agent deal failed, proving the Blue Jays right about his long-term value trajectory. Timing in contract negotiations matters almost as much as talent.
18: Barry Larkin (Cincinnati Reds, 1992)
Larkin’s 5-year deal with the Reds provided $113.5 million in added value. In 1992, he became just the sixth player in baseball to exceed $5 million annually—a figure that wouldn’t cover a decent middle reliever today.
His performance remained stellar throughout the contract. Larkin collected multiple All-Star appearances, won an MVP award, and showcased remarkable all-around abilities at shortstop. His consistency and leadership eventually earned him Hall of Fame induction.
Larkin’s combination of offense and defense created value in ways that made him more valuable than many flashier contemporaries who grabbed bigger headlines.
17: Gary Carter (Montreal Expos, 1978)
Carter’s 5-year contract with the Expos accumulated $113.5 million in surplus value. It featured a nearly static salary structure throughout—standard practice then but unimaginable in today’s escalating market.
By 1982, Carter earned less than the league average salary despite leading the league in WAR. He won a Gold Glove and a Silver Slugger award during this period. While the press hyped his contract when signed in 1978, his performance by 1982 made his compensation look almost criminal.
The value Carter provided behind the plate and in the batter’s box shows why catchers often deliver outsized returns on investment when they stay healthy.
16: José Rijo (Cincinnati Reds, 1991)
Rijo’s 3-year Reds contract provided $120 million in value—surprising for a player who doesn’t immediately spring to mind alongside other stars on this list. His incredible 1993 season ranks among the most underappreciated pitching campaigns of that era.
Arm troubles unfortunately derailed what looked like a Hall of Fame trajectory. Rijo attempted a remarkable comeback in 2001 after years away from the game, showing the determination that made him special.
His contract shows how sometimes the best values come from players who operate just outside the spotlight. Not every bargain wears pinstripes or plays in prime time.
15: Tom Glavine (Atlanta Braves, 1993)
The Braves secured their crafty lefty with a 5-year deal that created $121.6 million in surplus value. Alongside Greg Maddux and John Smoltz, Glavine anchored what many consider the greatest rotation in modern baseball history.
The Braves dominated the National League during these contracts, winning divisions with machine-like regularity. Glavine’s consistent excellence eventually earned him Hall of Fame induction, validating the team’s foresight in locking him up.
Fans of a certain age might remember Glavine starring alongside Maddux in the famous “chicks dig the long ball” commercial—his contract value proved much bigger than his star power.
14: Jorge Posada (New York Yankees, 2002)
Posada’s 6-year Yankees deal generated $124.5 million in surplus value—surprising for someone often overshadowed by more famous teammates. His appearance on this list might raise eyebrows among casual fans.
The contract covered six of his seven best career seasons. Remarkably, despite his production, Posada never ranked among the top-7 highest-paid Yankees during this period. He earned three All-Star selections and finished top six in MVP voting twice.
His steady presence behind the plate helped anchor multiple championship teams while delivering offensive production that catchers rarely provide.
13: Lou Whitaker (Detroit Tigers, 1983)
© Junfu Han USA TODAY NETWORK
Whitaker’s 4-year contract generated $127.6 million in surplus value for the Tigers. This deal perfectly showcases how dramatically underpaid star players were during this economic era.
His entire contract totaled less than $10 million—a figure many backup infielders earn today in a single season. During this span, Whitaker produced his best four-year stretch, collecting All-Star selections, Gold Gloves, and Silver Slugger awards.
Whitaker formed half of one of baseball’s greatest double-play combinations with Alan Trammell, creating value through consistent excellence that grows more impressive with each passing year.
12: Randy Johnson (Seattle Mariners, 1994)
Johnson’s 5-year Mariners contract earned $133.3 million in surplus value. The towering lefty transformed from a wild thrower with control problems into perhaps the most intimidating force on the mound in baseball history.
After harnessing his command issues, Johnson unleashed his devastating arsenal to win a Cy Young Award, lead the league in strikeouts, and post a dominant ERA. Despite his excellence, the Mariners only reached the playoffs twice during this period.
When Johnson finally hit free agency, his market value had skyrocketed based on the dominance he showed during this contract. His growth resembled a sci-fi transformation from promising talent to unstoppable force.
11: Dale Murphy (Atlanta Braves, 1983)
Murphy’s 5-year Braves deal generated $147 million in surplus value. Atlanta took a chance with the extension after Murphy’s breakout season came relatively late in his development.
The gamble paid off spectacularly. Murphy won MVP awards during the contract and placed high in voting during the other years. He provided approximately 28 WAR while leading the league in home runs, winning Gold Gloves, and collecting Silver Sluggers.
His clean-cut image and consistent excellence made him the face of the franchise during a challenging period for the organization. The Braves got a franchise player at discount rates.
10: Wade Boggs (Boston Red Sox, 1987)
Boggs’ 4-year Red Sox contract delivered $155.9 million in surplus value. The third baseman ranks among history’s greatest contact hitters, with some arguing he might be the best pure hit-collector ever.
His best 10-year stretch featured dominance across offensive categories. Boggs posted remarkable batting averages, on-base percentages, and OPS numbers while recording significantly more doubles than most contemporaries. This contract aligned perfectly with the peak of his abilities.
Boggs made hitting look as effortless as breathing. His approach worked like a sophisticated algorithm when everyone else was still using calculators.
9: Eddie Murray (Baltimore Orioles, 1981)
© Brent Skeen Imagn Images
Murray’s 6-year Orioles deal created $161.5 million in surplus value. The contract structure reflected the unusual economics of the early 1980s, when player salaries often remained static despite significant inflation.
While the average MLB salary more than doubled from 1981 to 1986, Murray’s compensation stayed relatively flat. Meanwhile, he averaged 5.4 WAR per season, led the league in important offensive categories, and delivered consistent excellence that eventually earned him Hall of Fame induction.
His switch-hitting prowess and defensive skills made him one of the most complete players of his generation. Murray quietly built a career that became more impressive after it ended.
8: Mike Schmidt (Philadelphia Phillies, 1977)
Schmidt’s 5-year Phillies deal provided $161.5 million in surplus value. The third baseman might be underrated among baseball’s generational talents despite his incredible achievements. He accomplished this remarkable feat twice during his career.
After signing in 1977, Schmidt became the highest-paid player in baseball for two years. He averaged an astounding 9 WAR per 162 games during those five seasons while collecting two MVP awards. His power, defense, and overall excellence make him arguably the greatest third baseman in history.
His greatness sometimes gets overshadowed in baseball conversations. Schmidt dominated like a blockbuster that critics loved but casual viewers somehow missed.
7: Rickey Henderson (New York Yankees, 1985)
Henderson’s 5-year Yankees contract generated $169 million in surplus value. The dynamic leadoff hitter established himself as perhaps the greatest table-setter in baseball history during this period.
Henderson reached base over 40% of the time throughout his career while stealing bases at an unprecedented rate. He averaged 117 runs and 76 steals annually during this contract while contributing over 7 WAR per season. Despite these contributions, awards voters often overlooked his unique skills.
No player before or since has combined Henderson’s specific talents—making his contract one of baseball’s greatest values. He changed games simply by standing on first base.
6: Miguel Cabrera (Detroit Tigers, 2008)
Cabrera’s 8-year Tigers deal generated $192.5 million in surplus value. Ironically, his final contract extension years later might top a “worst deals” list, showing how quickly aging affects value.
From 2008-2013, Cabrera posted an incredible 162 OPS+ while becoming baseball’s only Triple Crown winner since 1967. He collected two MVP awards during the extension and received MVP votes in all eight seasons. This agreement represents the highest inflation-adjusted dollar amount on the entire list.
His combination of power and contact ability during this stretch made pitchers look like they were throwing batting practice. Then Father Time arrived, as he always does.
5: Jeff Bagwell (Houston Astros, 1995)
Bagwell’s 7-year Astros contract earned $204.4 million in surplus value. The first baseman established himself as one of the premier sluggers of the 1990s, combining power with on-base skills and underrated defense.
His statistical averages during this period boggle the mind: 37 home runs, 122 runs, 120 RBIs, and 6.4 WAR per season. Bagwell received MVP votes in six of those seven years. Unfortunately, steroid suspicions clouded parts of his career, though he’s since been inducted into the Hall of Fame.
Bagwell even appeared in several baseball instructional videos during this period, sharing the expertise that made him such a complete player and tremendous bargain.
4: Alan Trammell (Detroit Tigers, 1981)
Trammell’s 7-year Tigers contract provided $206.6 million in surplus value. This deal represents one of the most dramatic underpay situations in baseball history. The shortstop negotiated personally without an agent, likely contributing to the team-friendly terms.
These years encompassed Trammell’s best performance, including his role in Detroit’s 1984 championship where he won World Series MVP. He appeared in multiple All-Star games, won three Gold Gloves, and captured a Silver Slugger award during the contract.
His partnership with Lou Whitaker made them baseball’s longest-running double-play combination and one of its most valuable. Together they provided championship-level production at budget prices.
3: Robin Yount (Milwaukee Brewers, 1979)
Yount’s 5-year Brewers deal delivered $238.5 million in surplus value. The timing proved incredibly fortunate for Milwaukee. While his initial five years were unremarkable, Yount’s performance exploded during this contract period.
His 1982 MVP season ranks among baseball’s best single-season performances. Remarkably, despite his elite production, Yount ranked just seventh on the Brewers’ payroll that year. His contract breakout aligned perfectly with Milwaukee’s competitive window.
Yount’s sudden emergence as a superstar created value that few contracts in sports history can match. The Brewers essentially got lottery-winner returns on a small investment.
2: Pedro Martinez (Boston Red Sox, 1998)
Martinez’s 7-year contract generated $255 million in surplus value for Boston. During this span, he delivered two of the greatest pitching seasons in baseball history—made even more impressive by occurring during the height of the steroid era.
Pedro finished in the top four of Cy Young voting six out of seven years while maintaining a remarkable 2.52 ERA when offense dominated the sport. His combination of dominance and consistency created value that few pitchers in history have matched relative to their compensation.
His performances at Fenway Park during this contract weren’t just pitching—they were performance art that left hitters looking helpless and fans in awe.
1: Albert Pujols (St. Louis Cardinals, 2004)
Pujols’ 8-year Cardinals deal provided an astonishing $301.5 million in surplus value—the greatest arbitration extension bargain in baseball history. This represents the only example of a truly generational player extending early and delivering on every ounce of his immense potential.
His consistency from 2004-2011 defied belief. Pujols led the league in WAR for six consecutive seasons while winning three MVP awards. He collected seven All-Star selections, four Silver Sluggers, and two Gold Gloves during this period.
The cruel irony? His inevitable decline perfectly coincided with his subsequent free-agent contract with the Angels, proving that even the greatest players can’t outrun time forever.
