Who Had The Best or Worst MLB Trade Deadline

0
Who Had The Best or Worst MLB Trade Deadline
© Matt Blewett-Imagn Images

Okay, okay, deep breath—because that was one monster of a trade deadline. If you blinked yesterday, you probably missed, like, five trades, two bullpen overhauls, and Carlos Correa literally teleporting back to Houston like it’s 2015 all over again. After a relatively chill July where most teams kept their powder dry, Thursday blew the lid off the kettle and reminded everyone why we love this game. We’re talkin’ fastballs, fast deals, and even faster decisions from GMs trying to make (or break) a postseason run.

Philly Makes Power Moves Without Paying the Price

Let’s start in Philly, where the Phillies came in looking for two things: bullpen fire and outfield glue. And guess what? They got both. Jhoan Durán wasn’t just the best closer on the board—he was the guy. And locking him up through 2027 without giving up Andrew Painter or Aidan Miller? That’s not just winning the deadline; that’s borderline wizardry. Sprinkle in Harrison Bader’s elite glove and career-high OPS? Boom. Instant upgrade.

Meanwhile, out in Seattle, the vibes have shifted from “maybe next year” to “this is the year.” Cal Raleigh’s been carrying a stack of bricks on his back, but even Big Dumper needs a breather. So Jerry Dipoto did something wild—he got serious. Eugenio Suárez joins Josh Naylor as mid-season pickups who don’t just fill holes—they send a message. This front office wants to win now. Like, right now. Not “maybe September,” not “if the rotation holds,” but today. That’s a sea change in Seattle.

Correa’s Homecoming Headlines Trade Deadline Shockers

And how about Carlos Correa? Back to Houston, switching to third base, stepping in to patch up a battered Astros infield. The Twins are imploding, the vibes were off, and now Correa’s back in a city where October baseball is the expectation. Storybook stuff, people.

Even the A’s got in on the winner’s circle. Selling? Sure. But they flipped Mason Miller and J.P. Sears for a haul from the Padres. And Leo De Vries? An 18-year-old shortstop phenom who might be anchoring the infield for a decade. For a team trying to reset (again), that’s a solid approach.

Speaking of the Padres… yes, they’re in both categories. Winners and losers. A.J. Preller continues to treat prospect capital like poker chips at a Vegas table. And hey, maybe that works—Mason Miller, Freddy Fermin, Nestor Cortes, O’Hearn, Laureano… all smart additions. But giving up Leo De Vries? That’s big. It’s like investing in instant noodles while cashing out your 401(k). Delicious now, potentially devastating later.

Mets, Dodgers, and Tigers Left Holding the Bag

Mets, Dodgers, and Tigers Left Holding the Bag
© Nick Wosika Imagn Images

Now for the teams that flinched—or just flat-out froze.

Minnesota, my goodness. Ten players out the door and not a whiff of direction in return. Twelve months ago, they were a playoff team. Now? A glorified clearance sale. It’s like ripping up the script mid-show.

The Dodgers were quiet, too quiet. Brock Stewart is fine. James Tibbs III is interesting. But for a team hanging onto a division lead by a thread—and with San Diego surging—this felt like an unusually chill approach from Andrew Friedman. Maybe Glasnow and Snell’s returns will patch things up, but that’s a lot of faith in some fragile arms.

The Mets… well, they made moves. Four key additions—all rentals. Eleven players out. That’s the kind of math that makes long-term planners break out in hives. Sure, they’re trying to win now, but sacrificing Blade Tidwell and a chunk of depth for guys who’ll be gone by Halloween? It feels like panic shopping with the credit card.

And finally, the Tigers. Still sitting pretty in the AL, yes. Still have a nine-game division lead, yes. But with teams throwing down for elite closers, Detroit reached for Kyle Finnegan—a decent arm with a mid-4 ERA and a one-way ticket to free agency. The bullpen needed more bite, and this… wasn’t it.

Bottom line? This deadline was wild, chaotic, glorious, and deeply telling. The October hopefuls have made their plays, the sellers have reshuffled their futures, and the rest? Well, they’ve got some explaining to do.

Play ball, people. It’s about to get real.

author avatar
Spencer Rickles Writer
Spencer Rickles was born and raised in Atlanta and has followed the Braves closely for the last 25 years, going to many games every season since he was a child.