When Matt Holliday helped power the St. Louis Cardinals to a World Series title in 2011, he cemented his legacy as one of Major League Baseball’s most dependable stars. Now, years after hanging up his cleats, the seven-time All-Star is making headlines again, this time for listing his extraordinary $12 million Oklahoma estate, a custom-built mansion that blends elite athletic ambition with refined luxury.
A 136-Acre Athletic Mansion Built From the Ground Up
Constructed in 2022 in his hometown of Stillwater, the property stands as a testament to both vision and precision. Holliday originally purchased the land for $3 million before transforming the sprawling acreage into what can only be described as a private sports sanctuary. The five-bedroom, six-bathroom residence is not merely a home; it is a fully immersive athletic retreat designed with championship-caliber detail.
For sports enthusiasts, the estate delivers an unmatched lineup of amenities. A full indoor pickleball court and indoor basketball court provide year-round training opportunities, while professional batting cages and a full baseball field reflect Holliday’s deep roots in the game that defined his career. The property continues to impress outdoors, with a putting green and tennis court, ensuring nearly every major sport is represented across the 136-acre grounds.
The crown jewel of the exterior may be the two-level swimming pool, complete with a waterfall feature that reportedly cost $2 million alone. The pool area, paired with a hot tub, outdoor kitchen, and expansive patios, creates a setting engineered for both recreation and large-scale entertaining. A guest house, a large barn, a gym, and a four-car garage further enhance the estate’s versatility, balancing leisure with everyday functionality.
$3 Million in Custom Interiors and Designer Detail
Inside, the mansion reveals approximately $3 million worth of custom furniture, meticulously selected to complement the home’s architectural vision. The main kitchen, living room, and hallways feature bespoke furnishings and rich hardwood finishes, giving the interior a polished, cohesive presence.
According to the listing by Wyatt Poindexter of The Agency, designer elements such as Gucci wallpaper and refined architectural detailing elevate the residence beyond standard luxury construction. Every corner appears intentionally crafted, merging modern elegance with warm, livable comfort. The result is a home that feels both grand in scale and intimate in atmosphere.
A Home Built for Fellowship and Lasting Memories
Yet beyond its amenities and craftsmanship, the home carries emotional weight. Holliday has emphasized that the property served as a gathering place, a space designed for connection. He described evenings spent hosting college students and professional athletes, sharing meals, stories, and meaningful fellowship. The layout, he noted, naturally invites community, encouraging guests to linger and engage in deeper conversation.
For a player whose career revolved around teamwork and clubhouse camaraderie, the home appears to have extended that spirit off the field. Since retiring from Major League Baseball in 2018, Holliday transitioned into coaching, joining the Oklahoma State baseball staff just one year later. The estate reflects both chapters of his life: the disciplined competitor and the mentor invested in developing the next generation.
Now listed at $12 million, the Stillwater mansion stands as a striking symbol of Holliday’s journey, from MLB stardom to hometown legacy builder. It is a property defined not only by its luxury and athletic focus, but also by the community and the memories created within its walls.
