The Braves are in a tough spot with the recent news that reliever Joe Jimenez will likely miss most of the 2025 season due to knee surgery. This blow to Atlanta’s bullpen was unexpected, especially considering it wasn’t an area the team had planned to revamp this offseason. But now, with one of their most reliable late-inning arms sidelined, GM Alex Anthopoulos faces a new challenge in filling that void.
With some payroll flexibility after recent offseason moves, could Anthopoulos be planning a big addition? Jimenez’s strong 2024 season made him an invaluable piece for the Braves, so finding a replacement with a similar caliber won’t be easy. The reliever market is deep, with plenty of high-impact options to consider though. Here’s a look at six potential fits who could help anchor the Braves’ bullpen in Jimenez’s absence.
1. A.J. Minter
Minter has been a mainstay in Atlanta’s bullpen and is known for stepping up in big moments. However, he’s coming off hip surgery in August, and his health raises some questions. A one-year “prove-it” deal might keep him in Atlanta for another season, giving the Braves a familiar option without a long-term commitment. If Minter can bounce back, he could fill a critical mid-to-high leverage role.
2. Aroldis Chapman
The flamethrowing Chapman, now 36, still has the ability to light up the radar gun, averaging 98.7 mph on his fastball last season. Although walks have become more of an issue for him, a move out of the closing role might allow him to be more aggressive in the strike zone. That strategy potentially makes him a useful asset in Atlanta’s bullpen.
3. Blake Treinen
Known for his lethal sinker/sweeper combo, Treinen’s success out of the bullpen has been a constant. At 36, he still has plenty to offer, but the Braves will need to weigh his cost carefully. If his contract demands are high, Anthopoulos may hesitate to invest heavily in an older player.
4. Tanner Scott
Scott was a standout after his move to San Diego last season. He finished the season with a phenomenal 1.75 ERA. He ranked in the 100th percentile in average exit velocity and is known for his ability to limit hard contact. Scott’s left-handed arm could give the Braves some serious firepower in late innings. His strong strikeout numbers make him a high-impact option to consider.
5. Chris Martin
Martin is a former Brave and posted a 3.45 ERA last season. Although he’s 38, his experience and durability could make him a budget-friendly option. His reliability could provide depth and stability for Atlanta even though he wouldn’t be a flashy replacement.
6. Devin Williams
Milwaukee’s star closer Williams could be on the move. The Brewers recently declined his club option for 2025. He offers serious value for his skill level with an $8 million arbitration projection. Williams’s elite changeup would bring a high level of control and effectiveness to the back of Atlanta’s bullpen.
Each of these options brings unique strengths and potential pitfalls. With a mix of high-leverage free agents and intriguing trade possibilities, Anthopoulos has a range of paths to explore. Whether he brings back a familiar face like Minter, looks at top-tier talent like Williams, or finds a middle-ground option in Martin, this offseason will be key in fortifying Atlanta’s bullpen for another playoff push.
