Here’s a wild idea for Atlanta Braves fans to chew on. What if Nolan Arenado could be the creative answer to upgrading the shortstop position? It’s not as far-fetched as it sounds, at least according to Sports Illustrated. While there are other options on the table, this unconventional move could be what Atlanta needs if their primary targets slip through the cracks.
The Braves could solely look at true shortstop player in free agency, but Atlanta GM Alex Anthopolous is known for creative deals. Per The Athletic’s Katie Woo, the St. Louis Cardinals third baseman Nolan Arenado has a better chance at being traded than he does staying with the Cardinals.
Let’s break this down. The Braves are no strangers to bold roster decisions. The idea of reconfiguring their infield with Arenado isn’t completely out of character. Yes, Arenado is a third baseman and Austin Riley is already solidified at that position. But that’s where creativity comes into play. Arenado, a 10-time Gold Glove winner, has reportedly been open to positional shifts before, such as a potential move to first base. Could the Braves persuade him to tackle shortstop instead?
Arenado has never played a single inning at shortstop, but his defensive pedigree speaks volumes. His .977 fielding percentage in 2023 was his best in three years. His elite glove would easily complement Riley on the left side of the infield. This would allow the Braves to maintain Orlando Arcia’s strong defensive presence as a utility option while significantly upgrading their lineup offensively.
Speaking of offense, even in what was considered a “down year” for Arenado, he posted respectable numbers: a .272 average, .325 on-base percentage, and 71 RBIs. Compare this to Arcia’s struggles with runners in scoring position, and it’s clear Arenado brings a much-needed clutch factor to the plate. Arenado’s ability to drive in runs—even in less-than-ideal conditions—could reinvigorate the Braves’ lineup.
Of course, this isn’t Plan A. Willy Adames, Bo Bichette, or Nico Hoerner might be more straightforward solutions. If those options fall through and Arenado becomes available, why not think outside the box? Atlanta has a history of turning high-risk, high-reward moves into success stories. Arenado’s potential resurgence could be the latest chapter. The Braves thrive on bold gambles, which could be worth considering.
