The Atlanta Braves have carved out a reputation for being patient and strategic. They often let the market frenzy swirl around them while they wait for the right opportunities. General Manager Alex Anthopoulos seems to be doubling down on that philosophy this offseason.
While fans are restless for big moves, one thing is clear: the Braves should potentially hold off on throwing their hat in the ring for Jack Flaherty, despite his strong rebound in 2024.
Flaherty’s 2024 campaign, split between the Tigers and Dodgers, was a tale of two halves. He looked great in Detroit, leveraging his curveball more than ever to generate a career-high 43.6% whiff rate and posting a 3.17 ERA over 160 innings.
Flaherty’s Home Run Rate in LA
But the change of scenery in Los Angeles revealed some troubling cracks. His home run rate skyrocketed, with nine homers allowed in just 55 innings, and the postseason spotlight wasn’t kind, as he logged an ERA north of 6.70 in every series the Dodgers played.
That kind of volatility is a major red flag for a pitcher likely to command top-tier money—especially for a team like Atlanta, where postseason success is the ultimate goal. The Braves have seen firsthand how critical it is to keep the ball in the park come October.
Flaherty’s penchant for giving up long balls and his inconsistent health history make him a risky investment, particularly when the Braves already have a strong top three in Chris Sale, Spencer Strider, and Reynaldo Lopez.
Instead of locking in another starter with a questionable track record, the Braves would be wise to focus their resources elsewhere.
Strengthening the bullpen or adding a potent bat to bolster their lineup could yield a far greater return. Anthopoulos has always prioritized versatility and value, and this approach aligns perfectly with his long-term strategy.
Atlanta doesn’t need to win the offseason headlines—they need to win in October. And signing Jack Flaherty doesn’t look like a move that will get them closer to that goal.
